查看完整版本 : What do these symphonies have in common?

symphonicdance 2016-6-1 01:24 AM

What do these symphonies have in common?

Just blowing a bit of water...

Brahms Symphony No 4
Dvorak Symphony No 9
Mahler Symphony No 7
Rachmaninoff Symphony No 2
Shostakovich Symphony No 10
Tchaikovsky Symphony No 5

- Popular works in concert halls.
- Written by composers at their "mature" composition age.
- Slow movement fairly lyrical (except may be Shostakovich's).
- E minor (aside : unfortunately, neither Beethoven nor Bruckner composed a symphony in E minor).

:smile_41: Which conductor had recorded all of them?  :smile_39: Not even Karajan.

[[i] 本帖最後由 symphonicdance 於 2016-6-1 01:30 AM 編輯 [/i]]

maulee2008 2016-6-1 11:53 AM

奇怪卡叔冇錄Rachmaninoff Symphony No 2

symphonicdance 2016-6-1 12:11 PM

[quote]原帖由 [i]maulee2008[/i] 於 1-6-2016 11:53 發表 [url=http://www.discuss.com.hk/redirect.php?goto=findpost&pid=442218280&ptid=25829067][img]http://www.discuss.com.hk/images/common/back.gif[/img][/url]
奇怪卡叔冇錄Rachmaninoff Symphony No 2 [/quote]

Indeed, why Karajan did not record this beautiful Rachmaninoff work :smile_41:  Will be a mystery forever.

Surprisingly, Ashkenazy had recorded all the mentioned ones.

[[i] 本帖最後由 symphonicdance 於 2016-6-1 12:22 PM 編輯 [/i]]

lula135 2016-6-1 03:13 PM

你唔寫出來我都無為意"馬七"是所謂的E小調(5個樂章幾乎完全不同調)

ozozoz 2016-6-2 06:59 PM

即使調性相同,六首作品似乎沒有什麼關連。如Brahms 4 & Dvorak 9結尾氣氛迥然不同;Mahler又自成一家。

Brahms 4 & Dvorak 9 & Tchaikovsky 5很多指揮都有錄音,但Mahler 7 & Rachmaninoff 2 & Shostakovich 10則否(甚至不錄Mahler & Rachmaninoff所有作品)。

印象中,Simon Rattle有全錄以上六首。Ormandy欠Mahler 7;Karajan欠Mahler 7 & Rachmaninoff 2。

symphonicdance 2016-6-2 08:51 PM

Not sure if Rattle actually recorded all six, too.  On the other hand, I just found Jansons, who also did all six.

[[i] 本帖最後由 symphonicdance 於 2016-6-2 08:52 PM 編輯 [/i]]
頁: [1]
查看完整版本: What do these symphonies have in common?